This is a topic of great interest and on which we have often tried to clarify. The Italian Supreme Court (Cassazione) recently intervened on this point, examining the fees of brokers in house sales and specifying that the amount is only due if the deal is concluded: accepting the purchase offer by itself is not enough!!!!
But let’s see better what has been clarified.
Real estate agency commission, when you pay
The Verdict n. 9612/23, issued on April 11st, 2023 by the Supreme Court says that – as established by article 1755 of the Civil Code – the Realtor has the right to commission from each of the parties, if the deal is concluded as a result of his intervention. The conclusion of the deal is therefore essential, as it is NOT enough for the promissory seller to accept the purchase offer from the promissory buyer.
But there’s more… according to the Consumer Code, “the clause that determines a significant imbalance for the consumer is void because it provides for the accrual of the right to commission at an earlier stage than the conclusion of the deal”.
How much should a Realtor charge?
Typically, Realtor’s commission to be paid by both the seller and the buyer ranges between 2% and 4% + VAT of the agreed purchase price of the property; it also includes the reimbursement of costs incurred by the agency for all the instrumental activities carried out up to the conclusion of the deal.
However, and also based on the peculiarity of the Case, these figures might change.
Basically, the entity of the commission remains negotiable between the Realtor and the Client.
When should the commission NOT be paid to the realtor?
If the real estate agent who took care of the sale transaction has not shown himself to be impartial or has omitted important and necessary communications/information for the successful result of the sale, it is possible to refuse to pay the commission. The commission to the real estate agency only for the visit to the property is not due.
Get in contact with us if you are thinking to buy home in Italy
Recent News & Events
The purchase of prestigious properties represents a safe and profitable long-term investment. This type of property presents very peculiar characteristics that make it particularly recognizable; among the various, the uniqueness of the property shines clearly in terms of location, historical-artistic value, enviroment, architectural character/personality and - latest trend - energy efficiency. The attention to [...]
Short-term rentals are confirmed as a formidable weapon for making income from properties purchased as an investment. But the tax authorities are tightening their shirts to intercept the owners of second homes and transactions, so as not to lose this important piece of revenue. Meanwhile, with a Verdict issued at [...]
Italy can request withholding taxes on short-term rentals. This was stated by the EU Court which (partially) agreed with the Italian State deeming the law on short-term rentals introduced in 2017 to be legitimate. The European Court of Justice has declared that the Italy can request information and data on the leases made [...]
The short-term rental regime was introduced into our legal system with Legislative Decree no. 50 of 24 April 2017, in article 4. This is a particular form of tax regime dedicated to the rental of residential properties for a period not exceeding 30 days. The tax regime for short-term rentals applies [...]
